Carly Rose Sonenclar takes on Justin Bieber’s “As Long As You Love Me” for her Top 6 unplugged performance on THE X FACTOR USA.
“You sang it better than Justin did,” said Demi Lovato. — Huhh!!
Carly Rose Sonenclar Sings “As Long As You Love Me” – X Factor USA
Previous post: Justin Bieber Living Life to the Fullest
Next post: Grammy Snub: Justin Bieber NOT Nominated for Grammy Awards :(
{ 100 comments… read them below or add one }
Next Comments →
STFU Demi! Nobody sings that better than Justin!
Follow me on Twitter guys: I_Rauhl_Bieber
I follow back!
she sings relly good and it wasnt her diseshion if u actuly watched the video u would no that it was brettney spears idea to sing that song
Yes, Justin is not the BEST singer in the world… He is VERY talented but seriously no one can sing HIS song better than him seriously
Obsessed much..yes….seriously get a bf
Some Boooody Your Annoying.
HELL YH! nobody
That. Bitch that is what came out my mouth when denies said that
No wonder Selena stop hanging out with that bitch that fat bitch I just started liking her but she have to ruin everything
Haha me to how can you sing someone else’s song better than them you can’t do anything better than the original
actually plenty of people sing better that the originals. Just as she did and just as justin did when he sang Chris Brown’s “With You.” Gosh sometimes I hate calling myself a belieber because y’all can be so ignorant and always take everything offensive and choose to side with Justin no matter what.
Carly is an amazing signer. Watch all her performances then argue your case please.
@ hey then please don’t call yourself a belieber I agree with u that Carly is an amazing singer and I’m a big fan of her but Justin is better than her it’s his song and he is better when he sings it because it’s his song and Chris’s brown with you he truly did sing it better than Chris if she did sing it better than him I would agree with you but she did not and to a belieber u should always be on his side noooo matter what or just don’t call yourself a belieber pleeeeaseeee
Guess what….???? You the biggest hater
(hey) I also like Justin but im not a belieber that’s just over obsessing over someone who don’t care about you and Carly sang that song amazing and obviously all of you girls like Justin bieber because he is hot and whateva shit like that but I’m not a big fan of him I just like his music and im happy that I’m not a belieber because you beliebers are ignorant and selfish ….I mean it’s not like she wanted to sing the song okay…..oh and stop obsessing coz its not gonna work ……lol ……so yes that’s what I have to say and you belieber bitch that’s your name nuh…..you say that you trying to be a hater……but you know what huh ????!!!!!!?? …,.,. You are the biggest hater
no one sings better than JUSTIN BIEBER ok
she dosnt sing better then him but she dosent sing bad eather and again it wasnt her diseshion on what sng she sang
she did great but no one can sing it better than Justin
demi !!
Yea I agree with ur opinion no one can sing better than justin!!!
all she does is whine and complain about being bullied. how long is she gonna carry tht out? andyway, shes just jealous of justins amazing talent.
IKR
Yes she whines and complains because it torments her everyday …but what do you know huh…..you probably bully someone that’s why you going on so and that bullying that she went through obviously works on her head ….so don’t judge her
i disagree with Demi….. she it good but not good that poeple will listen to her…… one thing is Demi your wroung she didnt sing better then Justin did ok!!! sooooo ya
Smilesss
actually people will listen to her. Exactly why she has been number one on the show the past 2 or 3 weeks.
And don’t be a hater. She’s a great singer, just like Justin was at that age. Don’t be one of those people going against her like the people that said he wouldn’t make it.
I totally agree with u.
THIS IS WHY I HATE DEMI LOVATO SHE THINKS THAT CARLY CAN SING BETTER THAN JUSTIN BIEBER IN HER DREAMS CARLY IS GOOD BUT I THINK SHE ISNT EVEN A MILLIONTH AS GOOD AS JUSTIN
You really are a maddie bieber seriously you ignorant….give the girl a chance I mean everyone wants a courier path and she wants to sing and in order to do that she can’t have mean people blogging crap and negative things about her
I think that Carly’s voice is boring she has talent but its low and boring she can hit some high notes but only if she yells to hit it. And I didn’t like the way that she changed the song at parts it made it annoying. Only Justin can sing this song cause hes amazing. I’m not hating on Carly just don’t like it.
You’re totally right
How about we hear you sing on x factor next year and let’s hear what note you can hit
tell that idiotic demi to suck off… I mean can anyone sing better than justin for his own song??? She is crazy n I knw y… Cuz she is a frnd of selena the crazy lady…
this is one thing i hate about this fanbase.you always as to bring Selena in shit that doesnt even invole her,like stfu. -_-
Are u Dom seriously how do you have the right to swear Demi …..what has she ever did to you….you stupid hater…mad bieber fan ….ay yurra
she was a great singer and it was just a lil beter then justin bieber
Ok now I officially HATE Demi or rather Dummy Lavoto. First, she unfollowed Justin bieber twitter when Justin and Selena supposedly broke up- now this skanky h#e wants to say that Carly rose sings Justin Bieber’s song better then jb can! w
w the nerve of this b!tch. It was Justin’s song first, how immature was that of Demi? Who agrees that Demi has never liked Justin?
You really need to get a life….you asking who has the nerve o do this and that….and you still have the nerve to call her a bitch…..honestly you really rude…..just over a song that Justin bieber sang now you wanna go all hating on Demi and I bet you can’t sing to save your life…..and Demi is a judge and she has to say the truth…she can’t now go and say that Carly sang crap because Justin beaver …….psshhhht
At somebody I would say you are being rude… I do not like Demi it is my opinion. She also looks like a tranny with a chin like a man.
haha sonnenklar in german means sunclear
Hahahahaha immature means Lola in English……seriously grow up
Nobody sings better than Justin Bieber, especially when it is there own song, She is good, but not as good as Justin.
I Love you Justin Bieber
True
JUSTIN BIEBRER SINGS 1000 TIMES BETTER OK SHE DOES SING GOOD BUT JUSTIN BIEBER SINGS BETTER EVER!!!!!!!!!YAY JUSTIN BIEBER !!!!! I LOVE U 4 LIFE!<3<3<3<3<3<3
Lol it’s not like he loves you back lokl
This someboooody chick is stupied talking bout how we beliebers are waisting out time excuse but your waisting you time fighting with us about something we already know and that is that demmi is a bitch who is just hatting on jb cause she dont got good hearing but ohh well belieber kno the truth so im out im not even gonna wais my time awsering all the coments like some bitch did
Hahahaha very funny Demi, but reality check! He wrote the freaking song so she cant have any credit for singing it better! He sings it so much better!! Justin is an amazing singer and that chic isnt anywhere near his potential or talent. So once she has that many hit songs and sold out concerts, then you can say she sang it better. Which she totally did not!!! And anyways she will never be as successful as him sorry hun!
Exaaaaaactlyyyy
Excuse me…..lol you really think he cares if you blog good things about him….hahaha….. Lol reality check it’s just a show and it wasn’t her choice to sing the song…..and don’t go on cursing the girl now….she will be successful one day…..I know you obsessed with the dude but don’t go cursing Carly…..you really mean …stop obsessing its never gonna work ….lmao
Uhhhh hey Demi…. ABOUT HELL NO
i dont hate Demi,but i dont love her either.what she said was complete shit,well too me.tbh Carly is a GREAT singer,but let’s be honest…..Justin WILL ALWAYS be the BEST.
Truee !
Aaaaaaah wrong…..you all crazy Justin bieber freaks
STFU Some Boooody. If u don’t like Justin y are u even on this site. 1. I don’t agree with Demi at all. 2. I’m not bashing people for their opinions on Carly or Demi or Justin unlike you but seriously u talking makes me want to puke!
Justin will always be the best, an demi is totally wrong in what she said, all she does is protect herself with the arguement of being bullied and having psycological problems, honestly I used to like her, but she is getting a bit annoying with all of her comments…
she probably just said that to make her feel good.
Hey that bullying works on her head okay ….it’s not her fricken fault that she got bullied and deny the reason why Demi said that was because uts baldy true
When i watch x-factor and when im listening to carly rose singing its not nice ! Seriously !! the judge doesnt know how to judge !!!! She sang it out of tune !! Stfu !
NOBODY CAN SING BETTER THAN JUSTIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
NO WAY…………IT’S NEXT TO IMPOSSIPLE
no one said that she sang better or that anyone sang better but u know what u dont have to hat cause if u where in her posishion u wouldnt want people to be haten on you
Thank you Mizziz bieber idk y people must hate her so much……amd I bet that if as long as you love me wasn’t jb’s song they all would of liked it
You stfu iynn because if you sing you will crack every window on earth oh and gayatri there us way better singers than jb example,,,.. Chris brown, Neyo ,,,etc
The SONG IS NOT LIKE THAT………….SHE JUST COULDN’T SING
BITCH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
that was so good
Demi was tacky in the way she spoke of Justin and Emblem 3. Carly sang it very well but left out the difficult part that Justin does very well-the rap part usually sung by Big Sean. This makes the song more difficult to sing since you have to shift from singing to raping than back again to singing the rest of the song. Carly can not best Justin IN SINGING THE FULL SONG with the rap part.
Yup!
Gayatri you a stupid hater okay…..the only one being a bitch is you….you going on for someone that don’t even know your name and ivan its called singing not rapping and that’s why they cut the rapping out and by the way carly rose wants to sing not rap
Love to have seen Carly sing a song by Demi then Simon saying she sang it better than Demi does to see how she reacts.
yakh yakh yakh yakh yah yakh yakh yakh yakh yakh yakh
her voice is sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo yakh and eeeeeeuuuuuuuuuuwwwww really yakh i just want that only justin can sing his songs no one else and she do it nop at all her voice is soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo yakh its not better see at the last they have written that
u do it better then justin
what the
what is this y she sing only do be famous then write your own song y only justin,s song u want to sing tell me i want ans only from justin and that lady
justin she do bad thing really bad thing
justin plz say her something y she do this
i really hate her
justin one thing iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii llllllllllllllllllllllllllllloooooooooooooooooooooooooovvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvveeeeeeeeeeeeeee uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu
really i love u justin i am saying true
You yah even the way you speak and spell lmao…..Justin dont love you back …..whaaaass you loser …….you can’t sing so keep your tackiness to your self
you talk like a loser one.!
No! Justin is better than anyone bitch! @demilovato : Stahp that! you, fat bitch! Half-chinned girl! Follow me on twitter @1DMcChrisBieber
Carly is amaaazing and I’m a big fan of her since I’m also 13 but what demi said was total shit no one can sing Justin’s songs better than him . And besides idk what she says she’s not an expert or a very big singer artist to judge Justin is soo much better than her ( Carly and Demi) Carly sang the song amazingly and I was soooo happy that she sang Justin’s song but ofcourse no one can be better than him in this song. I love Justin sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo much . So proud of you:):)
Ay ay mcChris you rude…..yoh you kak rude…….you stupid obsessed Justin freak and belieber forever you 13 that why you like Justin well grow up because he never gonna be your bf and all Demi did was tell the truth do stop hatin ………… Oh and you not Justin’s wife or mother so you do not have to be proud
Guys don’t hate on Carly she did not say that she hates Justin or something and don’t lie she is Avery good singer and she might win don’t be like that she is now in the same situation as Justin was before . I’ m not a hater of course not I love Justin and i’m a belieber and I think he’s the bessssst but u just can’t say that Carly sucks because she is amazing. But of course Justin is better than her but u have to say the truth about her voice.
I haaaaaaate stttuuupid ddeeeemi laaavatoo. I looooooove youuu soooooo much justttinnnnnnnn u r the beessst.
HAHAHA
yupp uu sang that song very very cool , but it’s very easy to sing like yyoouu i swear . try to sing as long as youl ove me like justin bieber and u’ll see that it’s to hard for uu?
She sings great and deserves to win contest and also showed respect for Bieber by singing his song. It was,however,not the whole song with the rap that would have made it more difficult to sing as I said before. justin sings the whole song easily.
Justin don’t love you back …….and brikena her way of singing is way harder ……..but you don’t know that ……and ivan she wants to sing no rap
awhhh.. isnt that the girl justin bieber favorites in youtube?? #Confused lol
nd alright maybe she ddnt sing it better than biebs, but yu kno jb was honored she chose his song.. she prolly was amazing.. too bad the day i decide not to watch it, she sings that.. smh
lol i willl watch it tho
she’s 13 nd she made it tht far in the x-factor.. she WILL b somebody.. just sayin.. 
-Alyssa
@iitz_ALYSSA
oh nd i sooo agree…
Dear Demi,
you could’ve atleast said sumthn like,
“oh, you almost sang it like justin”, or “Wow! you sung that amazing..!”
but better than jb… uhh idk
Truthfully it was better than bieber …”..michaelwanabe u are so right Carly rose does sing better but you know some people are to obsessed with mr biebs to face It …..miulein nobody is criticizing him okay……..and everyone hates Carly rose…..nd I mean comman sense Carly never even did anything to this people that don’t like her…….ilovejb u right and don’t hate jb …….I don’t like the people who like jb oz they so ignorant and to muh pride and a lot a much obsessed with him……
Oke ? Carly is talend but Justin it better.
*is*
SHE REALLY SINGS BETTER ,FACE IT!
that’s not true okay?
i agree that demi never like it justin beside i always think that cuz she is friend of the jonas bet i think was unnecessarily say that cuz she could just say other thing i think she say that cuz she don’t like justin and how other people can song better then the original and justin is super talented and a great singer so, i just tired of people who critics justin everytime for everything i just decided ignore all the tabloid rumors and haters cuz i know justin i believe in him i know he is a good boy and he is just 18 and he is learning about life and like he say he is not perfect and he is always trying to do the best he can no one is perfect so no one can talk mybe really difficult for him that everybory talk about him about his personal life when no one knows nothing or critic everything he says or does about his career and his personal life and people making up storys all the time i love justin and i will always support him cuz i am a belieber
I gotta say she did pretty amazing but you cant compare the two one she is a girl with a big voice (she has a very high range if u watch the XFActor u know) Justin is a guy and doesn’t have the highest range of voice like her so you cant really compare them! JUSTIN IS AMAZING AND CARLY IS AMAZING LETS NOT HATE ON THE 2.
She is grate. But I love Justin’s version.
SHE’S LIKE A MINI FRIGGIN SELENA. OMG SHE LOOKS AND ACTS SO MUCH LIKE HER…. WUT DA HEEEEEEEELLLLLLLLLLL!
Ok Hating on Demi doesn’t do anything but her compliment was foolish.How can someone sing Justin’s song better than himself..IDIOT:P
STUPID DEMI LOVATO…. No one sings that song (or any of his, for that matter) better than he can. I never did like that- well, for not having a better name at the moment, jack-ass, but I started to after hearing “Give Your Heart a Break”, I started to like her a little bit. This just killed that. But to Carly- she did a good job, but not that good….
NOBODY IN THE WORLD SINGS JUSTIN’S SONG BETTER THEN HIM DEMI!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I have seen some versions claimed to be better than Justin’s version and was not that impressed. They were good but slightly different from Justin’s in addition to which they omit the rap part which Justin could do better than any of them. Demi is probably still peeved at Justin over Selena [she is said to have unfollowed him on tweeter] so I see her tacky remarks as a putdown. She should just have said that Carly was great and that’s it. Carly, by the way, is a fan of Justin and praised his music in an interview.
i love the song she did but i dont thinks she could to it better the justin bieber i love u
I Really Love demi she is a big inspiration
But what she said oohh girl, carly’s voice is kinda okay but
Justin’s voice is so much better !!!!!!
that was a BIG mistake saying that
Demi is tripping theres no way she sings better than justin.
These comments are downright disturbing. Justin is 18 now, and a millionaire, do any of you think he’s the type of guy to go for a petty hateful groupie? If he was would you still idolize him? How about you ladies take on a dose of reality and try to become someone worthy of him instead of hating on those that are.
Carly is likely a fan just like you guys, who’s to say she wasn’t singing to him? Instead of disliking her how bout trying to be like her.
I didn’t expect that Demi would ever say “you sing better than Justin” especially for this song..
Next Comments →